The Crimson White

Films should honor, not exploit

Paul Greengrass directed 'United 93,' addressing the titular plane crashed in Pennsylvania during the September 11 attacks. Rotten Tomatoes

Drew Pendleton

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.


Email This Story






While the war movie has been a common genre of film since its inception, maybe the most crowning example of a post-war adaptation is Francis Ford Coppola’s “Apocalypse Now,” a 1979 opus that adapts Joseph Conrad’s novella “Heart of Darkness” during the end of the Vietnam War. Steven Spielberg’s “Saving Private Ryan,” made in 1998, does the same for World War II, albeit based on an original script, so it figures that a worldwide event would be a perfect fit for the big screen. But as much as these films included action and suspense, they never shied away or disrespected the everlasting effects or losses associated with war. They didn’t turn them into slam-bang blockbusters; they left that up to the fans to decide.

While adaptations of events like these can’t be entirely absent of action, they should be treated with respect. Paul Greengrass’ “United 93,” made five years after the titular plane crashed in Pennsylvania after a passenger uprising during the Sept. 11 attacks, is a perfect example. While we know how it’s going to turn out in the end, it doesn’t become a full-blown action movie. Its characters are human, and it pays respect to those who lost their lives that day while also functioning as a thriller. There are no added subplots like the romance in Michael Bay’s “Pearl Harbor;” there’s just the story that needs to be told.

There’s faith to be had in the filmmakers at work on these films. Casey Affleck and Mark Wahlberg both have Boston Marathon films in development; Wahlberg also has a Deepwater Horizon film in development with “Lost Survivor” director Peter Berg; and Michael Bay has “13 Hours,” which takes place during the Benghazi conflict, in pre-production. All events had tremendous impacts, and they need to be treated with respect. When these films hit the screens, we’ll be able to tell if that mission has been completed.

Leave a Comment
Navigate Right
Navigate Left
  • Films should honor, not exploit

    SPORTS

    Alabama soccer draws against Georgia

  • Films should honor, not exploit

    SPORTS

    Fans get glimpse of men’s basketball team at Tide Tipoff

  • Films should honor, not exploit

    SPORTS

    Alabama’s offense dominant in win over Missouri

  • Films should honor, not exploit

    SPORTS

    Jiwon Jeon making an impact for Alabama Women’s Golf

  • Films should honor, not exploit

    NEWS

    Recent podcast calls out SGA ties to Machine

  • Films should honor, not exploit

    SPORTS

    Alabama golf has strong showing in Fighting Illini Invitational

  • Films should honor, not exploit

    NEWS

    Update: Student shot at off-campus restaurant

  • Films should honor, not exploit

    SPORTS

    Alabama soccer secures win on road over DePaul

  • Films should honor, not exploit

    SPORTS

    Alabama hockey ready to take next step

  • Films should honor, not exploit

    SPORTS

    Alabama escapes with gritty victory over Virginia Tech

Serving the campus of the University of Alabama since 1894
Films should honor, not exploit